Charging Order Protection for Multi-Member and Single Member LLCs
In the course of their business, bankers routinely encounter single member limited liability companies ("SMLLCs"), entities commonly used in real estate and small businesses. Despite the prevalence of SMLLCs, there is a fundamental legal uncertainty as to whether the assets of an SMLLC share the same level of protection from its member's creditors as is provided to the assets of a multi-member LLC through the charging order remedy.
Depending on state law, bankers may or may not be able to reach the assets of their debtors' SMLLCs through a charging order. Furthermore, changes to Ohio law have recently been discussed in the Ohio Legislature which attempt to remove any uncertainty and would prevent bankers and other creditors from reaching assets of a SMLLC through a charging order.
The following analysis discusses recent case law from around the country examining a judgment creditor's ability to reach the assets of an SMLLC in which its debtor holds the sole membership interest. The LLC charging order is a remedy through which a creditor who has won a judgment may reach its debtor's membership interest in an LLC. State LLC statutes generally require the unanimous consent of all members (other than the assigning member) in order for the assignee of an LLC membership interest, such as a creditor who has attached its debtor's membership interest, to participate "as a member" in the management of the LLC. To protect this approval right of the other members in a multi-member LLC, a charging order entitles a creditor only to the debtor's share of distributions and assets upon dissolution, and not to the right to participate in the management of the LLC. This prevents the judgment creditor from selling the LLC's assets and distributing the proceeds to itself.
Continue Reading...
